Britain's Medical Research Council (Dept. of Health), ran a trial, PACE, reported on in The Lancet, UK medical journal in 2011) to evaluate - read, promote a psychological approach to treating ME (CFS in the USA).
The prime aim seemed to be steadily increasing exercise and telling the patient that it is all in his head. The 4 therapies used were: adaptive pacing therapy (APT), cognitive behavior (CBT), graded exercise therapy (GET), and specialized medical care (SMC). NB: APT does not mean that the patient decides how much to exercise, but standard amounts and times for exercise plus no naps.
Despite very limited improvement across all categories apart from APT, ie., between 3.4% decrease in fatigue, and 9.4% improvement in mean physical function compared not to a control group who received no treatment, but to the SMC group, and "severe adverse reactions" varying
between 1% to 3%, the government's decision was that the PACE trial was a success and was the way to go for CFS/ME patients.
Needless to say, the largest children's ME charity in Britain,The Young ME Sufferers Trust, disagrees, saying that a separate trial reported on in the Clinical Rheumatology journal in 2011, found that GET and CBT resulted in "worse physical function and bodily pain scores"; and
that "children's symptoms are exacerbated with GET".
The writer of the book, Osler's Web (the history of ME) commented that this was a way to avoid disability and medical payments as is seems to push the idea that CFS/ME is psychological in nature and that people can improve with more exercise than they would ordinarily consider.
And this despite, the year before, a group of 86 Member's of Parliament signing a petition to bring the issue of ME before Parliament, stating that ME is a genuine medical condition, that govt. funding "must be focused on the bio-medical factors involved and not simply managing the psychological symptoms". Now this concerted effort must have come about through ME patients and their families contacting their MP's and complaing about the way they were being treated - or not treated, sometimes (it is difficult to get diagnosed with ME).
So if anyone would like to make a comment on how they or their loved one was or is being treated by the medical community, please leave a comment.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Any reasonable comments - even if diametrically opposed to mine - are welcome